Treasure by character

Elgis
- Game 1
  - Healing potion
  - Naturalis Historia, Abridged, from Gregor the Naturalist
- Game 2
  - 250 gold pieces, share of Volstead House reward for saving Violet
  - Coca Powder from Yorvick Volstead
  - Cipher disk
  - 200 gold pieces, share from fencing Ulm's Monument catacombs spell lab circlet
Hamza
- Game 1
  - Healing potion
  - Ring of Greater Pulchritude, from Volstead House attacker
- Game 2
  - 250 gold pieces, share of Volstead House reward for saving Violet
  - Black Lung, Death Spiral, and Detect Fey spell scrolls from Ulm's Monument catacombs spell lab
Kiltak
- Game 1
  - ~~Dagger of Sorcerous Rebuke, from Volstead House attacker~~ (given to Virgil in Game 2)
  - Talisman of Ajana, taken from Penance Chapel attacker
- Game 2
  - 250 gold pieces, share of Volstead House reward for saving Violet
  - 200 gold pieces, share from fencing Ulm's Monument catacombs spell lab circlet
Virgil
- Game 2
  - Healing potion
  - Dagger of Sorcerous Rebuke (from Kiltak; originally from Volstead House attacker Game 1)
  - 250 gold pieces, share of Volstead House reward for saving Violet
  - Encoded spell and letters, decoded spells and letters, from Ulm's Monument catacombs spell lab
  - 1,100 gold pieces, share from fencing Ulm's Monument catacombs spell lab circlet
Party / unclaimed
- Game 2
  - Ash Turner's tabard, from looting Ash Turner's house
  - Brand Hill's family tree, from looting Ash Turner's house

Treasure by game